Is Red 40 Made From Insects? Red 40 vs Carmine

Quick Answer

No, Red 40 is not made from insects. It is a synthetic food dye produced from petroleum-based chemicals. The red coloring that comes from insects is called Carmine (E120), which is extracted from cochineal insects. Although both are used to color foods and drinks, they come from completely different sources.

Halal Alternatives

ABC Brand

A product of Indonesia that is halal-certified.

Ayam Brand:

A Malaysian brand with JAKIM certification.

I get this question often, usually from a worried parent standing in a grocery aisle.

The confusion is understandable, because both dyes show up as “red” on food labels. In this article, I will explain where Red 40 comes from, what carmine is, how to tell them apart on a label, and what scholars say about carmine. If you want the full ruling on Red 40 itself, read our main guide: Is Red 40 halal?

Does Red 40 Come From Insects?

No. Red 40 contains no insect, animal or plant material. It is made in a factory from chemical raw materials.

The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) lists Red 40 as a “certified” color. The FDA describes certified colors as synthetic colorings, and every batch must be tested and approved before it can be sold. In April 2025, the US health department and the FDA named Red 40 among the petroleum-based synthetic dyes it wants food companies to phase out. The legal standard for Red 40 is set in US federal rules at 21 CFR 74.340.

So when you see Red 40 on a label, there is no bug inside it. That one fact settles the insect question.

What Red 40 Is Made From

Red 40 is built step by step in a lab. Chemists join two petroleum-derived chemicals to form a bright red compound. This kind of dye is called an azo dye, a family of man-made colors.

You may see Red 40 under other names:

Allura Red AC
FD&C Red No. 40 (or Red 40, Red No. 40)
E129 (the code used in Europe and many other countries)
Red 40 Lake or Red 40 Aluminum Lake (a powder form used in coatings and candy shells)

All of these share the same coloring compound; the lake is only a different physical form. None of them come from insects.

Why People Think Red Dye Comes From Bugs

The rumor did not come out of nowhere. There is a red dye made from insects, and it has made the news many times. Here is why people mix them up:

Carmine headlines. Stories about coffee chains, yogurts, and candies using “bug dye” spread widely. Most readers remember “red dye is made from bugs” and forget the name carmine.
“Natural red” sounds safe. Carmine is often marketed as a natural color. People expect “natural” to mean plant-based, so the insect source surprises them.
Both are “red dye.” On a busy label, Red 40 and carmine look like two versions of the same thing. They are not. One is lab-made; the other comes from an insect.

What Is Carmine?

Carmine is a red dye made from cochineal insects. In Europe and many other countries, it carries the food code E120.

The cochineal is a tiny, soft-bodied insect, only a few millimeters long. It lives on prickly pear cactus and feeds on the plant’s sap. The female insect holds a deep red substance called carminic acid in her body. That substance is what gives carmine its color.

Because it comes from a living creature and not a lab, companies often call carmine a “natural” color. That word is accurate, but it can mislead. Natural does not always mean plant-based. Carmine belongs to the same family as other natural red food coloring, such as beet juice and paprika, and it is the best-known red food color derived from an insect. Lac dye is another insect-derived red, used in some Asian markets.

You can find carmine in yogurt, candy, gelatin desserts, juices and other drinks, and some processed meats. It is also widely used in lipstick, blush and other cosmetics.

How Carmine Is Made

Carmine starts on a cactus farm and ends as a red powder or liquid. The basic steps are:

Harvest. Workers collect the female cochineal insects from the cactus pads.
Dry. The insects are dried, often in the sun, then crushed into a dark red powder.
Extract. The powder is soaked in water, or a water and alcohol mix, to pull out the carminic acid. When the alcohol is removed, the liquid is sold as “cochineal extract.”
Fix the color. To make carmine, the extract is mixed with aluminum or calcium-aluminum salts. This turns the color into a stable, solid pigment called a “lake.”

The US rules define both products this way, and both are made from the same insect, Dactylopius coccus (21 CFR 73.100). It takes about 70,000 insects to make one pound of dye (source).

One more point matters for halal buyers. Carmine itself may be mixed or coated with gelatin to keep it stable, so the source of that gelatin also needs checking (LPPOM MUI).

Carmine Names on Labels

Carmine hides behind several names. If you see any of these, the product contains a cochineal-based color:

Name on label	Where you will see it
Carmine	US and worldwide
Cochineal extract	US and worldwide
Cochineal	Europe, UK and others
Carminic acid	Europe, UK and others
E120	Europe, UK, Middle East, Asia
INS 120	Countries that use the Codex code system
Natural Red 4 or CI 75470	Mostly cosmetics and technical sheets
Crimson lake or carmine lake	Older labels and art or cosmetic products

The E120, INS 120, Natural Red 4 and CI 75470 codes are confirmed by the FAO/WHO expert committee on food additives. For any other ingredient you are unsure about, check our ingredient list.

Red 40 vs Carmine: Side by Side

The table below shows how the two red dyes differ at a glance.

	Red 40	Carmine
Source	Made in a lab from petroleum-based raw materials	Crushed female cochineal insects
Type	Synthetic azo dye	Natural insect-derived pigment
Contains insects?	No	Yes
Other label names	Allura Red AC, FD&C Red No. 40, E129, Red 40 Lake	Cochineal extract, cochineal, carminic acid, E120, Natural Red 4, CI 75470
US label rule	Must be named (e.g., "Red 40")	Must be named ("carmine" or "cochineal extract")
Halal view	Generally seen as permissible on source; see our full ruling	Scholars differ; see the next section

Is Carmine Halal?

Scholars and halal bodies differ on carmine. Some major fatwa councils allow it, while many muftis, especially in the Hanafi school, say to avoid it. My job here is to lay out who says what, honestly and with sources, so you can follow the scholar you trust.

Bodies that allow carmine:

Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI), Fatwa No. 33 of 2011. Colors from cochineal are halal “as long as they are beneficial and not harmful.” MUI studied this specific insect with entomologists and found it resembles the locust, which the Prophet ﷺ allowed us to eat (LPPOM MUI).
Malaysia’s National Fatwa Committee, 100th meeting, July 2012. Using cochineal color in food, drinks and consumer goods is permissible (harus), as long as it causes no harm. The committee reasoned that, in the majority view, an insect with no flowing blood is not impure (Journal of Fatwa Management and Research, 2020; report).

Scholars and bodies that say to avoid it:

Darul Ifta Australia (Hanafi), 2011. Carmine is not permissible because eating insects is not permissible (fatwa).
Muslim Judicial Council, Cape Town. Cochineal is not halal, and consumers should avoid it, as reported by Shaykh Abdurragmaan Khan (SeekersGuidance).
Shaykh Rami Nsour (Maliki). The Maliki school allows some insects, but carmine production does not meet the school’s condition, so he does not consider it permissible (answer).
Bahtsul Masail of Nahdlatul Ulama, East Java. This Indonesian body ruled on insects in general and called carmine impure, reaching the opposite result from MUI (LPPOM MUI).

Why Scholars Differ on Insect-Derived Colors

The difference goes back to one older question: may a Muslim eat insects at all? The Qur’an tells us the Prophet ﷺ makes lawful what is good and forbids what is khabith, or foul (Surah Al-A’raf, 7:157). Scholars have long differed on whether insects fall under “foul.” Dar al-Ifta al-Misriyyah summarizes the schools this way:

School	View on eating insects
Hanafi	Not permitted, except the locust
Maliki	Permitted if the insect is killed for that purpose (a form of slaughter)
Shafi'i and Hanbali	Some insects not permitted, some permitted

Two more questions then shape the ruling on carmine:

Is this insect like the locust? The locust is a clear exception, by hadith, in every school. MUI looked at the cochineal’s biology and found it close to the locust. Others do not accept that comparison.
Does processing change the substance? In fiqh, this is called istihalah, a full change of a thing into something new, like wine turning into vinegar. Some argue that extracting carmine is such a change. Darul Ifta Australia studied the process and disagreed. They found the color is only extracted from the insect, not turned into a new substance.

A third point, purity, is separate from eating. Many scholars hold that a dead insect with no flowing blood does not make things impure. That is why some allow carmine in lipstick or clothing dye even if they would not eat it.

So how should you act? If your local scholar or halal certifier allows carmine, you may follow them. If you are unsure, the Prophet ﷺ gave us a simple rule: “Leave what makes you doubt for what does not make you doubt” (Tirmidhi, Nasa’i). Many Muslims in America and Europe simply choose products without carmine for that reason.

What This Means for Red 40

Nothing changes for Red 40. This whole debate is about insects, and Red 40 contains none. The question for Red 40 is different, and we answer it fully in our guide: is Red 40 halal.

How to Check if a Product Contains Carmine

You can spot carmine in under a minute with two checks: read the ingredient list, and know which vague words to question. The good news is that in the US and Europe, the law is on your side.

Read the Ingredient List

Look for any of these words: carmine, cochineal, cochineal extract, carminic acid or E120.

In the United States, the FDA has required food labels to name carmine or cochineal extract in the ingredient list since January 5, 2011 (Federal Register; 21 CFR 73.100). The FDA made this rule because of allergy reports. It also noted that Muslims, Jews, vegetarians and others want to avoid these colors.
In the European Union and UK, most additives must be listed with their category, such as “Colour,” followed by the name or E-number (EU rules). So you will see something like “Colour: E120” or “Colour: Carmine.”
In other countries, look for E120 or INS 120, and check the label in the language you can read.

Cosmetics in the US must also declare carmine, often with a line such as “Contains carmine as a color additive.”

What "Natural Color" and "Color Added" Can Hide

US rules let companies group most natural colors under general words such as “color added” or “artificial color” (FDA). Carmine is the exception, because it must be named.

Still, be careful in three cases:

Imported or mislabeled products. A product imported from a country with different labeling rules, or one labeled incorrectly, may not list carmine clearly.
Restaurant and bakery items. Fresh foods sold at a counter often have no ingredient list at all. Ask the staff.
Vague words in other countries. “Natural color” alone tells you nothing about the source.

One more change to know about: since February 2026, the FDA has said it will not object to “no artificial colors” claims on foods that contain no certified colors, even when they use colors from natural sources (Wiley). So a product colored with carmine can now carry that claim. Always read the actual color names.

Synthetic dyes like Red 40 work differently. They are certified colors, and US rules require each one to be named on the label.

Other Insect-Derived Ingredients to Watch For

Carmine is not the only food ingredient that comes from insects. The most common one is shellac, also sold as confectioner’s glaze or resinous glaze (E904). It is a resin that the lac insect, Kerria lacca, secretes onto tree branches. It gives the shiny coat on many candies, coated fruits and pills (cRc Kosher). Many scholars treat insect secretions, like honey or silk, differently from the insect’s body, and some count lac among them (SeekersGuidance). If you want a red color with no insect question at all, see our list of natural red food coloring from plants.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is red dye made from bugs?

Some red dye is, but not all. Carmine, also called cochineal extract or E120, is made from crushed cochineal insects. Red 40, the most common red dye in American snacks and drinks, is made in a lab and contains no insects. The ingredient list tells you which one you have.

Is Red 40 vegan or vegetarian?

Red 40 contains no animal or insect material, so by its ingredients it fits a vegetarian or vegan diet. Some strict vegans still avoid synthetic dyes because they have been tested on animals. That is a personal choice about testing, not about what the dye is made from.

Is carmine the same as Red 40?

No. They are two completely different dyes that happen to share a color. Carmine (E120) comes from cochineal insects. Red 40 (E129, Allura Red AC) is a synthetic dye made from petroleum-based raw materials. Their sources, label names and halal discussions are all different.

Is E120 halal?

Scholars differ. The Indonesian Ulema Council and Malaysia's National Fatwa Committee allow it, as long as it causes no harm. Many Hanafi muftis and several halal bodies say to avoid it, because eating insects is not allowed in their view. Follow the scholar or certifier you trust.

How can I tell if a food contains carmine?

Read the ingredient list. Look for carmine, cochineal, cochineal extract, carminic acid, E120 or INS 120. In the US, the law has required carmine to be named on food labels since 2011. For counter foods with no label, ask the seller directly.

Does kosher certification mean a product has no carmine?

Usually, yes. Major US kosher agencies, including the OU and cRc, treat carmine as not kosher. But kosher is not the same as halal. A kosher product can still contain alcohol or other concerns, so read the label anyway.

The Bottom Line

Red 40 is not made from insects. It is a lab-made dye with no insect, animal or plant material in it. Carmine (E120) is the red dye that comes from insects, and scholars differ on whether Muslims may eat it.

So read the label, look for carmine, cochineal or E120, and follow the scholar you trust. For the full ruling on Red 40, read is Red 40 halal. If you would rather skip synthetic dyes altogether, see our guide to Red 40 alternatives.

And Allah knows best.

Sources

Natural Red Food Coloring: Which Are Halal?

Mufti Eakub Sheik Nov 9, 2026

Quick Answer Most natural red food colorings come from plants, such as beet, red cabbage, paprika and tomato, and are generally considered halal by source.

halal_friendly_red_40_alternatives post feature image

Natural Alternatives to Red 40

Mufti Eakub Sheik Nov 7, 2026

Quick Answer Quick Answer: Plant-based colors such as beet, paprika, purple carrot and tomato lycopene are common replacements for Red 40. They are generally halal

Three varieties of mustard—yellow, Dijon, and honey mustard—displayed with ingredients for halal checking.

Is Mustard Halal? Dijon, Honey & Yellow Mustard Explained

Mufti Eakub Sheik Oct 30, 2026

Plain mustard is made from plant seeds, vinegar and salt, so it is halal. The real question is what else goes in the jar: many Dijon and specialty mustards add white wine or spirits. Here is how to tell which jars are safe.

Mufti Eakub Sheik

Mufti Eakub Sheik is the founder and lead researcher of Global Halal Guide (WhatIsHalal.org), where he examines food ingredients and products in light of the Quran, Sunnah and classical fiqh. An Islamic scholar and educator, he completed Dauratul Hadith from Befaqul Madarisil Arabia Bangladesh in 2011, followed by specialized training in issuing fatwas (Al-Ifta) at Shaikh Januruddin Darul Quran Madrasha in 2012. He later completed advanced specialization (Takhassus) in Hadith at Shaikh Zakariya Islamic Research Center in 2014 and in Tafsir at Markazul Huda Al-Islamiya in 2015. With over ten years of experience in teaching Arabic and Islamic studies, Mufti Eakub Sheik has developed strong expertise in Halal research, Islamic rulings, Shariah compliance, Hadith, Tafsir, and contemporary Islamic issues. His extensive Islamic scholarship and research background equip him to contribute effectively as a Halal Researcher, particularly in matters related to Halal and Haram assessment, Islamic jurisprudence, Shariah-based research, and religious compliance.